A new head coach usually means a step back in year 1
In a new head coach’s first season, FBS teams finished 2.3 points per game worse than their last two seasons predicted (90% interval -3.0 to -1.5; 269 coaching changes, 2016–2025). The drop was biggest when the old coach had left for another head-coaching job (4.4 points), and after a bottom-third season the new coach’s team landed about where expected (-0.5 points, interval -1.8 to +0.8).
- If your coach just left for a better job, expect year 1 to be rough: about 4.4 points per game below the team’s recent form, against 1.6 when a school made the change itself.
- Firing a coach after a bad season isn’t a quick fix, but it isn’t a setback either: the new coach’s first team usually plays about as well as the last two seasons said it would.
- A coach’s offense comes with him. How pass-heavy his new team is tracks his old team (correlation 0.53) more than the program’s own last season (0.27), so plan the roster around his system, not the old one.
Every coaching change since 2016
Why the reason for the change matters
When a school fires a coach after a bad season, the team’s recent results already include whatever went wrong, and the next season tends to look like them: teams coming off a bottom-third season landed -0.5 points per game against expectation (115 changes, interval -1.8 to +0.8), and 50% beat it. A coach who leaves for another head-coaching job usually leaves a good team behind, and often takes assistants and players with him; those teams fell 4.4 points short (65 changes, interval -5.9 to -2.9). Changes that weren’t a departure for another FBS head job fell 1.6 short (204, interval -2.5 to -0.7).
The drop is larger in the Group of Five (3.4 points, interval -4.5 to -2.4) than in the Power conferences (1.0, -2.0 to +0.1), and larger for first-time head coaches (2.9, -3.9 to -1.9) than for coaches who had run an FBS program before (1.3, -2.5 to -0.0). For scale, teams that kept their coach missed their own expectation by 6.9 points per game in a typical season, so a coaching change shifts the odds without deciding anything.
This season’s first-year coaches
The offense moves with the coach
Of 66 head coaches who moved from one FBS program to another, the new team’s pass-heaviness lined up with the coach’s old team (correlation 0.53) more than with the program’s own previous season (0.27). How a team spreads the ball between receivers, tight ends and backs travels less (0.18). For a roster, that means the quarterback and receivers who fit last year’s offense may not fit next year’s. The transfer portal board shows each program’s offense in plain words.
Method, data, and limits
Data. Head coaches, games and play-by-play from CollegeFootballData.com; power ratings are Sparvi’s (how they’re built): how many points better than an average FBS team a team should be on a neutral field, at the end of each season. 1,286 FBS team-seasons, 2016–2025, with ratings in the two seasons before.
Coaching changes. A season’s head coach is the coach with the most games that season, so an interim who finished a season counts toward whoever coached most of it. A change is a season whose head coach differs from the season before. “Left for another job” means the previous coach was a head coach at another FBS school the next season. “Had been an FBS head coach” counts jobs since 2014, where the coaching data start, so a few returning veterans count as first-time.
Expected rating. A straight-line fit of the end-of-season power rating on the two previous seasons’ ratings, estimated only on teams that kept their coach and leaving out the season being predicted. The effect of a change is the actual rating minus that expectation. Intervals are 90%, from 2,000 bootstrap resamples of teams.
Offense. Pass-heaviness and target spread are the first two dimensions of Sparvi’s team-system analysis (run/pass mix by situation, and how passes are spread between positions), compared for head coaches who moved directly from one FBS head job to another.
What it can’t tell you. Why a coach changed beyond the categories above (health, scandal, a buyout), roster turnover that came with the change (the transfer portal moves fast after a hire), or assistants who moved with the coach. Changes are not random: a school that fires its coach after a bad year differs from one whose coach was hired away, which is why the article compares them separately. A season of 6.9 points of noise per team means single teams say little; the averages are what hold up.
Code: cfb/carousel/ · Data provided by CollegeFootballData.com. Sparvi is not affiliated with the NCAA, any conference, or any school.
Model version. CFB power rating v1.0.0 (experimental: validated before the backtest harness existed; its harness port is pending).